Game #40: Uncharted Waters (SNES) - From Pirate to King (Finished)

It's a relief to reach the end of this game

Now, I don't mean to say I didn't enjoy the game. I did. However, the quests to track down specific ships drag on for far too long. There's just not enough information. It's possible to find a ship in the open seas, but if it reaches the edge of the screen it could disappear completely. Also, while the above is not the final screen, I felt it was better than this.

Which is the same screen after death

In preparation for my first serious battle against Ali's warships, I focused not on investing in the various mercantile establishments, but putting that money towards purchasing a fleet of carracks. I'd yet to find a shipyard that offered galleons, which comprised most war fleets and pirates. Trade routes became easier with each ship I bought as I made more money with each trip from the increased cargo capacity. Finally, after assembling a full fleet, I sought out Ali. Last known location was somewhere off the coast of Southern Africa.

Cape Town is one of the piddly ports around the coast of Africa that offers no more than a place to restock

I made it all the way to Cape Town before I had to turn back due to insufficient resources (a full crew burns through rations very quickly). With no sign of Ali, I decided to instead turn my attention back to exploring and discovering unknown ports of call. I filled my ships with sugar, firearms, and max money to afford provisions at the various ports. I started by surveying the entire area of the Mediterranean Sea. Istanbul, which was at war with Portugal, held no ill will towards me and even welcomed me. Purchasing goods at Turkey was inexpensive as the market was at the lowest possible. This allowed me to make quite the profit buying art and selling it elsewhere.

During this time I even made a couple of ill-fated voyages to explore Russia and North America, both port-less

On the open water there are a number of options. Most have to do with management of the fleet. Strangely there's a menu option to pick a direction to move, but it's faster to simply use the d-pad without calling up the menu (alternatively pressing L or R will rotate counter or clockwise). More useful are the options to cast anchor, which keeps the fleet stationary, and the debark options to either enter a port or camp on land. While on land the crew can make repairs, set sail, or search for either water or treasure.

During my exploratory phase I decided to see what changing rations from 50% to 30% would do to my crew, it wasn't pretty

It's possible to gather information on ships and ports by investigating. Survey, available once a sextant is acquired, gives the longitude and latitude in 5 degree increments based on the current screen. Negotiate works best with friendly ships, and is a good way to gather additional information. Communication with enemies or pirates is a quick way to start a battle. Initiating a battle is a another option, but I rarely used it unless I knew an attack was imminent. The last two options have sub-menus for stats about the fleet and giving orders. Orders include adjusting rations (note, if it goes below 50, then crew start to desert), distributing gold to mates, dismissing mates, and dismissing a ship. Honestly, none of the orders are useful.

After many failed attempts to find Ali off the coast of Africa, I found out that he was headed for Istanbul... now I wait

It's difficult to describe the frustration I felt while trying to track down one ship in the vast ocean with only a long. and lat. who knows how many days old, and by the time I arrived the ship is nowhere in sight. My only recourse: return to an inn, get a new location, and hope I can guess why they are traveling along that path. The only way I've successfully found a target was through sheer luck while waiting at a specific port. Good news: Ali was headed for Istanbul, so I waited nearby. I built up some funds in the area, and upgraded my fleet. Even better news, Istanbul had galleons available.

Purchasing my first galleon!

Soon after my first purchase, Ali finally turned up. I initiated the attack. It was a hard fought battle. Options in battle are quite limited. Move, wait, look, fire guns, rush, or flee is all that's available. Battle experience and strength of each mate plays a large role in determining attack strength. Gun type is also relevant. Ships can be outfitted with saker, culverin , or cannons. Honestly I can't see any benefit to using saker as they're weaker than culverin, but have the same range. Culverin are mid-range damage, but have an extra tile of reach over cannons. By the end of the game I had everyone equipped with cannons except for my flagship.

Sizing Ali up while in battle

Protecting the flagship is key. Losing that results in a complete loss, for either side. A flagship fleeing off the edge is another way to end combat. There's also a time limit, which is the number of turns before the sun sets. Apparently night battles aren't an option. If neither side wins before the sun sets, then it's a draw. This never happened while I played. In most battles, the AI wasn't smart enough to protect the flagship. I only lost a single battle: I was surprised with a bad formation and my flagship was surrounded. Whichever side initiates combat gets to move first. Combat experience is heavily weighted towards sinking or capturing ships.

Every victory is a great victory

There are two ways to take a ship out of commission: reduce either its hull or crew to zero. Both are reduced by taking direct fire, but crew is lost faster by rushing an adjacent ship. In fact, when two ships are touching, firing guns is not an option. I tended to keep my crew light, and relied heavily on my guns taking down the flagship. Accuracy of guns isn't a factor; if it's in range it'll hit. Damage is dependent on battle experience, possibly strength of the captain, and number of guns. Number of crew may also play a role, but I'm not certain. Victory over Ali won me a sizable amount of gold, enough for another galleon, and a gold bracelet to gift to the princess. I named the galleon Ripali, and headed back to Portugal.

The next quest involved my first map for buried treasure

The king congratulated me, promoted me, and then days later requested I bring him the mythical Silver Ladle. Rumor at the inn was that someone in Mecca by the name of Selma knew where to procure it. After saving up for the trip around Africa, buying a couple more galleons, I made my way to Mecca only to be told I really needed to speak to someone in Azov. Then it was Naples. Then, I acquired the map above. Showing this map at various inns suggested it was to the northwest.

Gathering water from natural springs

As this was going on I started to attract hostility from the Spanish. Apparently they didn't take too kindly to taking over the investment market and stealing allied ports. I was now attack on sight material, but they were hardly a threat (see above for the one exception). This necessitated a moderate crew size, which caused rations to deplete quickly. Since I wasn't sure how far away the treasure site was I decided it was best to set sail from London with as much food as possible. Ports are the only way to get food, so taking a ratio of about 2:1, I banked on my ability to search for water in the middle of the trip. Success was found on my second trip out.

Probably the longest quest out of them all, but I enjoyed it more than finding random ships

After this I was rank 6 and counting the days before the king would give me his next task. I was at 23K fame, and with a max of 50K according to the manual, I figured I would need to reach each 10K mark to get the quests for rank 7, 8, and 9. Fastest way to get fame seems to win support for Portugal. I stuck around the Mediterranean getting back all the ports taken from Portugal while I was away. Spain is very aggressive, but Turkey less so. In fact, Turkey never had a single allied port beyond Istanbul.

Tip waitresses enough and they start giving you the low down for random ships

This was enough to get the next quest: find the Hydra Ring. The waitresses at the inns directed me from Alexandria to Vera Cruz to Venice to Naples to Genoa before telling me that the pirate Gonzales had the ring. On the trip out to Vera Cruz I took a trove of firearms to the Caribbean, sold them at each port, and bought support for Portugal. In addition to fame, this also crippled the Spanish influence and their economy. Not as many ships attacked after that (or possibly I'd wiped most out by then). Problem with having high hostility with a foreign country is a random encounter at their allied ports where they attempt to arrest me. When caught they confiscate all trade goods.

Where's the fight option? Where's the bombard port option?

Gonzales was headed for Da Nang, and his last known location was on the eastern side of Africa. I raced around the coast towards Da Nang, which I learned is in Vietnam. When I arrived (converting every port along the way to Portugal) I found a very small port with only a restock option. I suppose this is the type of port a pirate would call home. No sign of the pirate. So, I made the best of it and traveled into China and Japan. There were a lot of trade goods. While spices are worth twenty times as much in Europe, the value per unit is too low. It was much better to invest in either Chinese silk, Japanese silver, or Arabian quartz. When I made it to the next port with a waitress Gonzales was suddenly spotted near Europe, so I made chase once again. By the time I arrived he was circling the Caribbean and headed back to Da Nang.

Best way to find a ship, wait at their preferred port by casting anchor

It took Gonzales 6 days to emerge once I arrived. I have no idea what he could have been doing inside for that amount of time. I tried to peacefully bargain for the ring, but negotiating with pirates always initiates a battle. The king was delighted to have his treasure, and again sent me on my way with a higher rank. Only two more to go! I went to London unloading my money by investing in the shipyard. My hope was they would eventually have a mega-galleon. Unfortunately there's no way to check without selling one of my own, so I was waiting for them to max out. After a couple of trips back and forth the king suddenly had some urgent news for me. The princess had been kidnapped. Simancas from Spain was the culprit.

Waiting outside Seville was again the best strategy

Simancas fell like all the others, and I returned to Lisbon with the princess on January 27, 1509. The manual suggests it'd be quite the feat to complete the game within 20 years. Here it is in seven. I'm sure others have done it faster, but 20 years seems obscene. Returning to the king with the princess in tow started the ending sequence. Surprising as I wasn't actually able to reach the final rank. I wonder if it required easing into the fame a bit more. When the king thanked me he mentioned how I routed all the pirates. I'm not sure that's quite true, but it's not like there was a list of them.

Which would you choose?

I chose the princess' hand in marriage as my reward. This resulted in the king abdicating the throne so I could rule in his place. He mentioned how he had planned to marry her to Spain. Honestly, after the way they've treated Portugal I can see why the king can't trust his own judgement any longer. I didn't explore the other options, but if you know the results please comment. The princess and hero sailed off into the sunset. It's a bit strange... in the sequel the Franco family isn't the royal family. Is this the only ending? On to a quick rating, and then the next game.

Elapsed Time: 21h35m (Final Time: 34h43m)

Literally sailing into the sunset

Combatant - There's little tension during combat. Most of the time, it's targeting their flagship is simple. Strategy is minimized. The AI doesn't vary between opponents or even countries. Stats seem to matter, but it's hard to determine how much influence they provide. Combat is beneficial as a strong fleet will have a lot of gold and enough reserves to act as a temporary port to restock. The gold usually covers the loss of men and ship damage. In the end though, it's better to act as a merchant to make money.
Rating: 3

Admirer - While there's no feedback for how stats advance, it's obvious they rise from use. By the end of the game there's hardly any customization as stats easily max out. It's not clear what the various figureheads for the ships accomplish, and the ships always look the same. This is the first game where I was actively fighting the controls to make the ship head the direction I wanted.
Rating: 2

The happy couple

Puzzler - The game does well with it's main quest. It's always possible to get the current step from any waitress, but if there's no active quest there's no motivation given. I'm not sure about side quests since everything leads to fame, which seems necessary to advance the main quest. Searching for the treasure with the map was my favorite quest. The multiple ways to complete most quests is encouraging for general exploration.
Rating: 3

Instigator - The story is built on the idea that the player is supposed to amass a nest egg and marry the princess. It builds up slowly, but never really advances much beyond that point. The NPCs are helpful for information, but history and lore are rather light. I never felt involved in a large story arc as the quests were handed out in pieces that rarely connected.
Rating: 3

So happy...

Collector - There are a variety of items to purchase, but most are bought and forgotten. Treasures can be gifted to the princess, but (like many things) there's no explanation how this influences anything. There's no knowing how many treasures or items are actually in the game.
Rating: 3

Explorer - The graphics and music are good; I enjoyed the soundtrack quite a lot. The world is quite large, and completely open from the beginning, only limited by food and water. While finding ports is nice, I hoped there was more to discover. Every town is basically the same, and it's hard to get a sense for actually discovering new land.
Rating: 6

Final Rating: 20 [33%]

Well, my history at least; the age of exploration is long gone

At this point I'd say that's a fair score. While I enjoyed the game, it falls short of a pure RPG. Even though it scored enough on the scale for inclusion, it doesn't hit a lot of the points to rate among the best RPGs. Most edge cases will fall into this area. If you enjoy this time period or a simple simulation game it's a fun diversion, but as an RPG it doesn't fulfill the itch. After the first day I was already looking forward to getting to the next game. Buck Rogers: Countdown to Doomsday is a strange game to bring to console, and I'm curious to see what steps they took to port it. Judging by the lack of a sequel I can guess it didn't do too well.

Game #40: Uncharted Waters (SNES) - The Life of a Peaceful Merchant

Game 40

Title: Uncharted Waters
Released: November 1991 (NES -- 1992 SNES)
Platform: SNES (NES / Genesis)
Developer: KOEI
Publisher: KOEI
Genre: Sim-RPG
Exploration - Top-down
Combat - Turn based (party based)
Series - Uncharted Waters

Aside from the sequel, Inindo seems to be the only other game in this series that made it to the US

Deciding what's an RPG or not is difficult, especially for games like this. Combat is usually a deciding factor, but in this case it's really the open world, trading system, and a small amount of character advancement. While it has turn-based combat, it plays such a minor role in the beginning that it's easy to forget it even exists. This is one of those edge cases that I felt should be included for its unique experience. The game was released for the NES, SNES, and Genesis in the US, and from what I've seen there are minimal version differences. I chose to play the SNES version due to cost and console preference. I was lucky enough to find a complete copy. The manual has been more helpful than the map, but it's nice to have both.

Way to work the title of the game into the game

The player controls the sole member of the Franco family. While you can name him, it defaults to Leon if no other is chosen. Stats for charisma, wisdom, intelligence, courage, and strength are randomly rolled along with bonus points. These slowly raise through use, but knowing when they've increased and why is a mystery. With such descriptions as "sense of mission" and "determination" I'm not really sure how they factor into the game. With those values set, it was time to name the ship and begin the adventure.

*Plop*

The game starts off in the port of Lisbon, capital of Portugal. I had some advice from the manual to sell off my current stock of trade goods, and purchase sugar to sell at the next port. Most ports specialize in at least one trade good that can be bought low and sold high at other ports. I got my business going by taking sugar to Bordeaux, buying grapes to sell in Antwerp, and lastly pawning off more sugar to London. I then took a shipment of either porcelain or wool down to Lisbon and repeated the process. At first I didn't have this full route down though because discovering ports required me to be right next to them.

Ah, there it is... wait, where?

The map that came with the game is fairly accurate to the real world. Unfortunately, the game is not. Although I found London, locating Antwerp or Hamburg took some extra equipment. Once I made some nice cash flow I invested in a few items like a telescope and sextant. The telescope helped me spot ports from over half a screen's length away, and the sextant meant I would never get lost as I was whipped around at the mercy of the wind. Controlling the ship is difficult. All you can really do is aim and hope the wind and current pushes the fleet in the right direction. The manual says the winds and current change based on the time of year, but I have yet to determine a pattern. In any case I'd rather push through slow waters than wait an extra month or two for the right trade wind to pick up.

Various equipment is available: icons and weapons help in battle, and amulets protect the ship from danger -- it's not clear exactly what they do though

Simply trading and getting my name out there increased my fame ever so slightly. This score, along with sailing level and battle level, seem to be what impresses mates to join the fleet. Mates are different from the rest of the crew as they can captain other ships. Each ship needs their own crew, but they can share the water and food supply of the entire fleet. There's still a message when a single ship runs out though, so there might be some penalty for that. If there's trouble on one of the ships the crew will silently dwindle, and then the ship will suddenly vanish.

Yeah, I misspelled Sebastian... oh well

Eventually people sought me out to complete trading missions. At first they're easy things like sugar, wool, or art, but soon they'll ask for things like coral and ivory that take months of travel to gather. The first time I sailed to the Americas I actually lost one of my larger ships, a Bergantin. It simply vanished in the Bermuda Triangle (might have had something to do with only having 20 crew members). Once I gained enough fame through carrying out merchant missions, the king of Portugal summoned me for a very special mission. It was on one of these missions I was seeking out the coral. Luckily my other four ships carried on to complete it.

My first mission, and it's uhm... it's up in London, where exactly is "all over"

Ports have up to seven points of interest depending on location. The first is the dock, which is used to shuffle supplies and men; restock food, water, and lumber (used to repair ships away from port); and set sail. This is naturally at every port, but some distant ones only have this.

A greater number have a lodge, inn, and market. The lodge allows the player to look at stats of the crew, fleet, or port. The most important of these is probably the port where it's possible to see the current market swing for goods, which ranges from 50% to 150%, and the popularity of each nation with that port.

Lisbon on the second day of the game... prices drop soon after to 80% and never really recover

The market is the central place to buy and sell goods, check current local prices, and invest in the local trade. Investing in the market increases support for Portugal, and will eventually increase the number of trade goods sold. If the popularity of a country reaches 80 or more, then the port is considered allied with that nation. This increases revenue for the king, and more importantly gives myself the opportunity to get a discount when purchasing goods.

At the inn it's possible to tip waitresses for favors, or buy a round for the bar and hear the local gossip. This is also the location to seek out mates and crew. Whether or not mates are available is random, and even if they are present they won't always join: probably dependent on fame and experience. To hire crew just toss out a few hundred coins and see who signs up. I thought the idea of having a big crew was to survive storms or battle with a serviceable ship. I hadn't entered combat at the time, so I kept my crew to a minimum. After all, the more crew, the faster I ran through my rations.

There's also gambling, but with a max bet of 50 I found trading paid faster

Even fewer ports have a shipyard and a guild. The guilds are where it's possible to buy equipment. Equipment ranges from items that assist (invisibly) with combat and sailing to more useful (read as obviously helpful) like the telescope and speculum. The speculum gives a bird's eye view of the surrounding land, and marks any ports I've already discovered. The shipyard is the place to buy (used or new) and sell ships, fix up my current ships, remodel a ship, or invest. In addition to increases popularity for Portugal, investing in the shipyard can unlock access to better ship types and figureheads. This is where remodeling comes in; a figurehead can be attached for some added defense. Remodeling also has options for changing the type of guns to use, which I'll get into when I talk about combat next post, and renaming a ship.

Hello Nintendo Hotline?

Lastly the castles, only three exist in this game and correspond to the three major countries at play: Lisbon, Portugal; Seville, Spain; and Istanbul, Turkey. Wait, why isn't it Constantinople? Isn't that historically accurate? In any case, outside my own country, and only if I'm on friendly terms, I can visit the other castles. Half the time, I get granted an audience where I learn about a country's sphere of influence (i.e. get a list of allied ports). It's good information for learning about what ports are out there.

As for Lisbon, I can request gold or men when I'm in good favor with the princess and king. I haven't tried to ask for gold yet as I don't want to have the possibility of paying interest. Savings serves as a bank where I can store up to 10,000,000 money. This is very helpful as there's a cap of 60,000 that I can hold at any one time no matter how big my fleet is at the time. The secret call is used to speak with the princess. Meetings come more easily with more ranks. For each completed mission from the king I get to move up one rank. There are nine, and my best guess is that reaching Duke is at least the first major goal. Some missions are as easy as taking a letter to the king of Spain while some are more time consuming, like getting coral from Santo Domingo. Each rank increases the market discount possible from allied ports by 5%.

Ways to impress a girl... tell her you love her, give her flowers, or give her presents

The majority of my time has been spent trading, making money, and just exploring. After I maxed my fleet at five ships I focused on buying bigger ships. Trading with the new world wasn't really worth it since it took so long to reach, but the game paces itself nicely by having the king give missions that slowly expand the area required to advance. Once I reached max gold I then focused on investing in ports, which greatly increased my fame.

Living the good life

Before too long I had reached rank four, and it was much easier to invest as I received huge discounts from purchasing at allied ports. At one point all the ports in the Mediterranean were allied with Portugal. Pisa was integral as it sold art, and everyone else was paying a premium for it. I had yet to set foot in Turkish waters though, as I had heard Portugal was at war with them. I wanted to avoid combat as much as possible with my small fleet of two Carracks and three Latins. Of course, all that would change I was thrust into the middle of the war with Turkey.

Don't you have war fleets to handle that?

Well, I can't exactly turn down the king, can I? I never tried honestly as I too afraid it'd affect my rank or fame. I suppose it's time to finally trade in the Belle and my other Latins for Carracks. Then it'll be time to hunt down Ali. The local gossip is he's been seen near the southern tip of Africa. I guess my only hope is to just run into him at some point. It's a great big world out there, and I expect it'd be pretty difficult to find a single ship in the vast ocean. Next post I'll go over combat, and the anguish of attempting to track down Ali.

Elapsed Time: 13h08m (Total Time: 13h08m)

Game #39: Final Fantasy Adventure (Game Boy) - Mana Mana (Finished)

Game 39

Title: Final Fantasy Adventure
Released: November 1991 (June 1991 JPN)
Platform: Game Boy
Developer: Square
Publisher: Square Soft
Genre: Action-RPG
Exploration - Top-down
Combat - Action
Series - Mana (Seiken Densetsu)

Thankfully a short game

I've been looking forward to seeing what games I missed on the Game Boy specifically. We had the handheld in the house, but we never had any games beyond Final Fantasy Legend (not even Tetris). I suppose we didn't travel enough to get more, and we had the major Nintendo consoles to keep us busy. Still, I feel like I missed something special with this game. I don't have the nostalgia built in for this title. While playing through it I could see a fun game, and it had its moments, the repetitive dungeons soured the experience. I remember enjoying Secret of Mana, so I'm glad the series had its start, and I'm looking forward to seeing how it evolves going forward. Maybe it's the Game Boy as a platform that limited the scope of this action game.

The story in a nutshell

The game begins with the naming of a boy and girl. The boy takes the lead, while the girl takes her place as sidekick and eventually kidnappee. Not much is known about where he came from, only what he does currently.

*Plop*

The current empire is known as Glaive. The hero, who I named Zeni, met up with his fellow fighters in their cells after their respective fights. Every day they battled for the amusement of the dark lord, who cared not when they die. Willy, a fellow fighter, succumbed to his wounds during the introductory sequence. He suggested I seek out the Gemma Knights to defend the power of Mana against the Dark Lord. Not sure how he knew so much, but he pointed me towards a man named Bogard near the falls. On the directive of another captive fighter, I charged the monster entrance in the arena to find the exit.

Wait a minute! I was risking my life fighting some tiger monster for your amusement and you weren't even watching?!

As I escaped I overheard Dark Lord and Julius, his commander, discussing the matter of the Mana Tree on top of the waterfall, and a girl that was the key to reaching it. I was spotted, and in my haste to escape I ran my back up against the falls. The Dark Lord blasted me into the falls, and I came too near the town of Topple. In town I learned nothing. Seriously, only more talk of a mysterious girl, the mana tree, and an old man that lived near the falls. I actually found old man Bogard before I found the girl, but he wouldn't speak to me at all.

Without the girl his dialog stops at "Go away!"

The girl was hiding out a couple screens below the path I walked around the river. There I discovered her guardian, Hasim, was mortally wounded. The girl, who I named Gani, was on her way to Wendel, but first needed to consult with Bogard. Since we were both headed to the same place, and honoring Hasim's dying request, I escorted her to Bogard. The old man noticed the Pendant of Mana, which was passed to Gani from her mother. He recognized it from many years ago when the Vandole empire attempted to use the power of Mana to take over the world. It was Gani's mother that helped foil their plans. Bogard provided a mattock to break rocks on the path to Wendel. There I was to seek out Cibba, but the road was treacherous.

I knew we should have stayed in the same bed... you know, for safety

Even though we had planned for rocks, it was tall grass that actually did us in. We were stuck, with no other option than to bed for the night at some shady looking inn. Should have known better it being free and all. Before drifting off to sleep Gani imparted the cure spell to Zeni. Asking others about her produced dumbfounded looks. Some other guests commented on a mirror that revealed people's true nature, and a key to a nearby cave where the mirror was held was in possession of some lizardmen to the south. All it took was defeating them, and exploring the cave. Inside was a man who offered to help me as many young women had disappeared from that inn.

Using the sickle I found in the cave to take down some two-headed dragon

The mirror I earned from the dragon was used at Kett's inn to dispel the guise of the man that guarded the entrance to Mr. Lee's private quarters. Revealed as a werewolf, I battled my way to the basement. There I rescued Gani from a coffin. On the way out I had to fight Mr. Lee, a vampire. I've noticed that most Game Boy games have limited enemy AI patterns, and once learned it's easy to avoid their attacks. I arrived in Wendel to the south thanks to the sickle that cut through the tall grass. There I met with the man that helped me in the cave. In the large house in the center I found Cibba waiting for me.

Maybe Zeni never had a mom

With Cibba's guidance a message from Gani's pendant of Mana was revealed. An image of Gani's mom said they were part of the Mana family, seeds of the Mana Tree. She sealed the path to the tree with the pendant. The Gemma Knights are sworn protectors of the tree. After the image faded the man who helped me in the cave suddenly appeared to tell me the dark lord had arrived, and he would take Gani to a safe place. Zeni, being the gullible type, said, "Okay."

I'm not even sure who this is lying on the ground, but I got knocked back into him and had to read his dialog multiple times

The man turned out to be Julius, the dark lord's right-hand man. Really Zeni? Shouldn't be letting Gani run off with random men when you're the one supposed to guard her. Julius overpowered me, and Gani was kidnapped. When I came to, Cibba told me Julius escaped to the west in his airship. Unfortunately the cave west was a living cave named Gaia that only enjoyed the taste of silver. The silver mine had a cart that needed to be oiled, only available in a shop to the south.

Trying to aim with the axe proved very difficult, so I eventually switched to the sickle

At the bottom of the mine I found Watts, and he joined me until the end of the cave. A large centipede type creature guarded the silver. It took some time to defeat as it crawled across the screen and disappeared into various holes. With the silver, Watts made some equipment, which he generously sold to me. Bogard joined me on the other side of the cave of Gaia. Julius' airship was refueling nearby. Gani was trapped inside a cell with no way out, except maybe the window. Bogard stayed behind to ensure she wasn't taken from it while I scaled the outside to the window.

Finally doing the smart thing and separating the pendant from the girl

Before I could get Gani out though, Julius showed up and blew Zeni off the side with a fire spell. I guess at some point the airship took off without my notice and I was now in a different part of the world. I landed on a thatch covered house, which just so happened to belong to Amanda, a fighter from Glaive that had also managed to escape. Too bad she was in some kind of trouble, and took the pendant from my unconscious body. Someone in the town of Menos told me of a chocobo egg nearby. The chocobo is a great partner as it allowed me to ignore all the enemies and travel faster over land. Jadd, a desert town to the west, was where all the real excitement took place. With a poison gas field, and complete silence.

Well that's something

Jadd was under the iron grip of Davias, with the ability to curse others by transforming them into animals. The only cure were the tears of Medusa, but her cave was concealed in the desert. Only a random boy knew the location. He wouldn't divulge the secret without something in return: a bag of fangs. I think this is the first RPG where I had to grind on a certain kind of enemy to get a random drop. I only thought to do this because one time they dropped a chest and it was empty. So, not only is the chest drop random, but the fangs aren't always in it. Even with the clue it took quite a while to find the cave.

What a clue...

Even knowing the correct oasis didn't help much... finding the cave was completely by random chance

Inside the cave was Amanda, who had taken the pendant to exchange it for her brother, cursed by Davias, her only recourse now was to fight Medusa and get her tears. During the battle things didn't go quite as planned. Amanda was bitten, and you know what they say... (no game, it's not the same as vampires). Well, without tears from the original Medusa, Amanda offered her own and asked me to slay her before she finished transforming into a monster. Not really even thinking about it, and just pressing the A button to advance the text (also the attack button), I killed her with a single swift strike. Her tears freed her brother Lester, and with his help I tracked down Davias.

Here's one of the many status effects: turning into a moogle (their first appearance)

Now, I haven't talked much about the game since it's pretty basic. There are spells gained at set story events. Weapons are discovered throughout the world, and most of them are necessary for some kind of navigation puzzle. Enemies are sometimes immune to particular weapons, so expect to switch often. Most attack spells are useless, and it's better to save MP for healing HP, except when a status effect hits. Moogle is special as it can't be healed, but poison, stone, and darkness are easily cleared up with magic. Each enemy defeated increases the hero's gold and experience. Levels thankfully come quickly and they restore HP and MP to max.

At each level you choose a stat to focus on, and two related stats increase as well

Davias, like most bosses was a pushover. With his dying breath he laughed at the fact that the pendant was in the hands of Garuda, and he was flying to Glaive. Lester played his harp to clear the gas from the path to Mt. Rocks, which took me to the castle. I fought through a giant metal crab, a cyclops to win a morning star, and a golem as I made my way to Glaive. A bridge that spanned the waterfall collapsed behind me for no reason, cutting off my escape. Inside the castle I faced off against a Chimera guarding Gani. In the middle of our escape I ran out of keys. Luckily there was a shop inside the castle that sold them; however, I think it might be possible to become stuck as doors sometimes re-lock themselves. Save while behind a locked door with no key, and there's no way out. A bit of an oversight that I sidestepped through pure luck.

Someone want to try to decode?

At the top of the castle I faced off against the Dark Lord; however, Zeni again sent Gani off to get kidnapped because it was too dangerous to have her around during the battle. Julius found her, and he had the real pendant. I'm not sure the Dark Lord knew his pendant was a fake. With Gani under Julius' control she reversed the flow of the waterfall and unlocked the path to the Mana Tree. Julius sent me swimming down it before ascending up the water. It's strange falling down the same waterfall and ending up in a different location. This time I fell pretty hard, and couldn't move. My pet chocobo found me, and carried me to the nearby town of Ish.

Dr. Bowow and the newly christened Chocobot, the hydroplaning chocobo

Once I'd recovered from my wounds I found Bogard in a nearby bed, back broken and bedridden. The chocobo injured its leg at some point, and was fixed with a robotic leg that allowed it to run across water. Bogard then told me of the legendary sword Excalibur. It's location was known only to Cibba, so I traveled back to Wendel; however, he wasn't home and there were no obvious clue as to where to find him. Actually there was one clue. Most NPCs retained the same text throughout the game, so imagine my surprised when there was one that did. She told me Cibba traveled to the town of Lorim, on the other side of a snowfield. I got lost for a bit, but eventually found the frozen Lorim. Cibba was trapped inside a room, door encased in ice. The town was frozen over due to Kary, another easy boss.

Why am I trying to carry you?

Cibba gave me the bone key to unlock the Floatrocks Cave beyond the Ammonite Coast. Inside was the legendary Rusty Sword... plus side, I fought a Kraken, and a monster with the strangest spelling of Ifreet.

The translation could have used a bit more polish

Cibba then directed me to find Dime Tower, and he pointed me to Dr. Bowow for help. The good doctor sent me on a quest to defeat Lich, the hardest boss in the game (seriously, I died twice), to recover the nuke spell. Nuke was the only thing powerful enough to destroy the crystals in the desert that would reveal the hidden Cave of Ruins. Inside that cave was a platform where I thrust the Rusty Sword into, which caused Dime Tower buried deep in the desert to rise once again.

Does this guy look familiar to anyone else?

Inside the tower I found a robot named Marcie. He was created by Dr. Bowow 50 years ago, and left to wander endlessly. Also inside was the history of the Vandole Empire. They were the ones that created the tower, and it spoke of a child of hope. I've already gathered that was Julius. In fact most of the tablets of history only reaffirm what I've already learned. On the roof I fought against Garuda. Beyond him was a bridge that connected back to the castle of Glaive, and the waterfall beyond, but it collapsed before I could cross. Marcie threw me, and fell with the tower. It was a very touching moment. Up the waterfall I ascended to face off against Julius. One last lengthy tower climb commenced with many bosses including a dragon, a red dragon, and a dragon zombie.

Many puzzles throughout the game revolved around freezing enemies with the ice spell and positioning them on certain tiles

Finally, after many enemies, I reached the summit and the grove of the Mana Tree. A random woman (maybe Gani's mom) gave me Excalibur, and ushered me on to the final battle with Julius. Honestly, after all this time, Julius was kind of a let down. He had three forms, each progressively more difficult; however, I had collected 3 elixirs from random battles, which nearly fully healed and restored my MP. Without those it'd be quite a bit riskier. The Mana Tree was destroyed during this epic battle. Linked I suppose to Julius' life force, when he fell so did the tree.

Gani's mom instructs her on the way to become the next tree

However, there is hope. Gani is part of the Mana family, a seed of the Mana Tree. The last in fact. She will become a new tree, but she will also be the last. Zeni, a Gemma Knight now, must guard and defend against further attacks in the future. With that, the game was over. Most of it was enjoyable, but some of the dungeons dragged on for far too long with little challenge. I think I've been spoiled with other games, and it wouldn't surprise me if all Game Boy RPGs don't live up to other titles of the same era.

Good-bye

Elapsed Time: 8h33m (Final Time: 8h33m)

Combatant - Combat was challenging in the beginning only due to low HP. Once I gained a few levels it became easier to both kill enemies faster and tank damage. The balance remained weighted in the player's favor until the very end (sans Lich). There were weapon options, but spells sorely lacked punch. The nuke spell might have been the most powerful, but physical attacks were sufficient.
Rating: 4

Looking forward to his other creations on more robust hardware

Admirer - The controls are solid, unlike similar games where hit-boxes make little sense and the possibility of stun-locks exist. The level up system allows for a bit of customization, but the character always has the same abilities. Nothing changes on his sprite when new armor is equipped. Weapons do look different though, and have varying ranges.
Rating: 4

Graphics were pretty good

Puzzler - The random puzzles that do exist are frustrating with little to no hints. I don't think anything is technically a side quest, but the main quest is ever present and never lost (discounting the puzzle in the desert, which I'm not sure how it really fits with the world). Unfortunately there really isn't much going on here aside from combat.
Rating: 2

Is it you I should blame for the puzzles?

Instigator - The story plays out at a good pace. Zeni never really picks up on the whole don't let Gani out of your sight idea. Townspeople are mostly around for fluff. More than half of what they say is completely useless. The player doesn't have any influence over how the story progresses. No choices whatsoever.
Rating: 4

I think you missed a spot... or five

Collector - Inventory is greatly limited, and by mid-game I was dumping items. Mostly I wondered what items like Crystal, Wisdom, and Nectar did when I used them. Gold constantly flows in, and it's easy to purchase everything as it comes up. Equipment and items are kept separately, but it's only items that tend to fill up. There's no way to know if everything has been collected. In fact, it might be possible to miss the morning star altogether.
Rating: 3

The music, especially the scores in the later part of the game, is really well done

Explorer - The graphics, music, and sound are very well done for the Game Boy. Exploring the world is a little underwhelming. There's not much to explore or find. The accessible world is limited at various points by falling from the sky or bridges collapsing for little reason.
Rating: 4

Final Rating: 21 [35%]

I never understood why they use Square and other times Squaresoft

Overall I found the game fun; however, I don't think I'd recommend it to anyone that isn't a fan of the genre. It's rather basic, and the final rating reflects that. The action stays fresh as new weapons are introduced regularly, but navigating the dungeons is tiring.

Next up Uncharted Waters. I've been looking forward to a good exploration game, and I hope this is it. This should be a lot of fun. I have a complete copy, so I've been reading the manual and looking over the map the past couple of days. Seems the story is a bit of a mystery.

Below the Cut: Pirates! (NES) and Pirates! Gold (Genesis)

(Source: Game Oldies)

Pirates! and Pirates! Gold - Rating(8 RPP)
1) 1 - Character Advancement: practice/experience based advancement, stat or level increases, multiple classes or characters, customize characters
2) 0 - Combat: character stats used for combat, additional combat options, turn based
3) 1 - Items and Equipment: store to buy and sell, equipment decisions, item decisions
4) 3 - Story: main story at the forefront; world full of hints and lore; descriptions for objects, people, and places
5) 2 - Exploration: open world from the beginning, visited locations remain open
6) 1 - Quests and Puzzles: side quests not related to the main quest, puzzles and riddles to solve

What I'd really like to see is a fully fleshed out pirate themed RPG. Of course, that may come soon with Uncharted Waters on the horizon, although I have a feeling that's more of an edge case (albeit with character stats and advancement). Here we have Pirates!, a port from PC to the NES, later remade for the Genesis--re-titled Pirates! Gold. What makes this game compelling is how it handles a slowly unfolding story of a fresh privateer as he takes to the seas. The Caribbean, simulated during the 1600s, is fully realized with many real world towns, random ships and historical pirate encounters, and a hidden story if you dig deep enough. It's also possible to make one trip around the bay and retire.

(Source: Game Oldies)

Unfortunately it lacks character advancement in every respect. It is possible to build up a crew of men (which act more or less like hit points), ships (that only increase cargo hold capacity), and goods, but the player's skill is the only determining factor for success. Combat happens in three ways: ship, land, and duels. During ship combat you select one from your fleet and face off against one ship of the enemies. Land based combat is probably the toughest of them all, there are multiple units or squads of men, and deciding how to direct them against enemy troops is difficult. (I've never successfully won one of these, but thankfully they're rare.) Dueling happens quite often, either against a ship captain, port governor, or various nemeses found through uncovering the story.

Some of the points on the scale I gave are a little shaky. The only character choices are at the beginning where you can choose country of origin, difficulty, and a special perk. The only items are trade goods, food, and cannons. It can be hard to differentiate the side quests from the main, but what pirate game would be complete without buried treasure, which count in my eyes. I enjoyed the Genesis version more than the NES, and recommend it as the superior iteration; not just for enhanced graphics and music, but the controls are better. So, not an RPG, but still an enjoyable game. Standard disclaimer that I only played each version for about an hour, so let me know if I've missed anything.